After she finished, he told her:
“I like you, you’ve got that confidence, you got the stage presence, I feel like you’ve been doing it forever. I didn’t love the song. If I’m really being honest, the song is like an R&B-Monica joint – it’s cool – but I think you’re broader and bigger than that. And you can take on more challenges. I love Monica, don’t get me wrong, it’s a cool song for her, but I think, I just feel something different for you. I like you. You’re Diana Ross.”
We don’t think he was throwing shade, but a SandraRose reader felt Randy wrongly dissed Monica. Do you agree?
The judges’ comments begin at the 2:00 mark.